"We purchased the matte finish with the rectangular envelopes. We love them! They came out exactly as it appeared on the screen. I wish we had used pictures that had similar lighting though. Our arrangement made the edited pictures by our photographer look almost too saturated. For instance, the pictures with red tones next to the ones taken in natural light were a little disruptive to the flow of the eye. The product is excellent quality and showed up several days earlier than quoted even with standard shipping. We especially loved the design and wording...it is so us!"